A woman says she feels responsible for a tragic mistake at a New York hospital.

Shirell Powell mistakenly took a stranger off of life support and now she’s suing for unspecified damages, reports the New York Post.

Powell said she sat for nine days at her dying brother’s hospital bedside at St. Barnabas Hospital in the Bronx until one day, she finally arranged for doctors to take her brain dead brother off of life support.

The woman proceeded to arrange her sibling’s funeral when officials revealed that someone on staff had made a big mistake.

It turns out Powell’s brother Frederick Williams was actually in jail and the dying man was a different person with a similar name.

According to Powell, she hadn’t heard from her brother for weeks when she got a call from the hospital on July 15 saying Frederick, 40, was unconscious from an apparent drug overdose. Powell visited the man whom she assumed was Frederick; he had a swollen appearance and tubes covering his face.

News 4

The aunt of Fredrick’s two teenage daughters, Brooklyn, 17, and Star, 18, said the family was crying hysterically when they said their final goodbyes and Powell authorized the hospital to withdraw him from life support. She recalled:

“It was very devastating. I was crying.

That is my baby brother, so it was really hurtful. I was worried, hurt, crying, screaming, calling everybody. It was a horrible feeling.”

It was only after a medical examiner discovered the man’s true identity, nearly a month later, that she got a call on August 16 saying the dead patient was Freddy Clarence Williams, 40.

Watch the video below:

St. Barnabas staff recovered Freddy’s social security number but still identified him as Powell’s brother, say the court papers.

According to the Washington Post, corrections records show Frederick was arrested on assault charges and held on Rikers Island on July 1, 2018. Powell said:

“I nearly fainted because I killed somebody that I didn’t even know. I gave consent.

On the one hand, I’m thankful that it wasn’t [my brother]. On the other hand, I killed somebody that was a dad or a brother.”

St. Barnabas hospital told the New York Post that the lawsuit is without “merit.”

According to the suit, Frederick Williams had been treated before at the hospital and his records were still on file at the time someone contacted his family.

Powell has not been able to obtain information about Freddy Williams to send her condolences to his family.

Watch the video below:

About the author

Tiffani is a writer for Dearly. She is from New York City. Prior to working for Dearly she covered fashion news and managed social media for various digital media outlets.

Leave a comment

3 Replies to “Woman Gives Hospital Permission to Take Brother off Life Support — She Learned Later the Man Who Died Wasn’t Him”

  • Bea 1 year ago

    How the hell could that have happened when usually people have ID ON THEM , and That too would also be in question as to how was he bought to the hospital? Via ambulance or dropped off ??? That should play an important roll in this type of situation. Someone who would be brought in by squad would usually at any rate have ID ON THEM … and or someone cohearent to give the EMTS AND PARAMEDICS INFORMATION REGARDING THE PATIENT . Police are usually sent to the scene when 911 is dialed and the person states THIER emergency to the call center ,depending on the situation police would obtain the patients name & Address and pass that information on to the Squad. Factoring room for insurance or to contact members of the patients family . So how was this gentleman BROUGHT TO THE HOSPITAL???
    Or was it just a drive and drop !!!!
    Sad situation either way and so many people inn the hospital, Dr’s ,nurses , secretaries ARE ALL NEGLIGENT !!!!

  • Anonymous 1 year ago

    I don’t she is responsible for what happened. Although tramactic to her and her family as it is. She had no idea that the staff had made such a mistake.
    It’s tragic for his real family as they didn’t get to see him before he was taken off life support. But it still comes back to whose really responsible for this mess. The court will sort it out. And I pray for all involved.

  • Anonymous 1 year ago

    Is she suing in behalf of the family of the person she “killed”? Or just looking for money.

In response to:

Woman Gives Hospital Permission to Take Brother off Life Support — She Learned Later the Man Who Died Wasn’t Him

Your email address will not be published.

We are excited to announce Dearly has joined forces with Mama’s Uncut. Helping Mom’s across the United States answer questions on life’s big challenges.