Police and residents of a southeast Georgia community are trying to determine how two teenagers could go missing without anyone reporting their disappearance to authorities.

Mary Crocker had not been seen in months, and her brother, Elwyn Crocker Jr., had not been seen since November 2016 — until December 20, 2018, when both bodies were discovered in their dad’s yard after police responded to a welfare check, reports Fox 5.

Effingham County Sheriff’s Office

Effingham County authorities said 14-year-old Mary and Elwyn, who would be 16-year-old, were found buried behind their home in a woodsy area of their backyard.

Days before Christmas, police acted on a tip from a concerned individual who noticed Mary had been missing for weeks and feared she was dead, reports the Daily Beast.

During the visit, her family told authorities that the child lived with her biological mother in South Carolina. However, police searched the home after they were given conflicting information.

They found Mary’s body, but they also found the remains of her brother — who hadn’t been seen since he was 14.

Posted by Elwyn Crocker on Tuesday, December 7, 2010

Five people were arrested and charged with murder in connection with the children’s deaths, including Mary and Elwyn’s father, Elwyn Crocker, 49.

The father of three worked as a local Walmart Santa weeks before the grisly discovery. Elwyn’s third son, who suffers from cerebral palsy, is still alive.

Effingham County Sheriff’s Office

His wife and the kids’ stepmother Candice Crocker, 33, step-grandmother Kim Wright, 50, the step-grandmother’s boyfriend, Roy Anthony Prater, 55, and Crocker’s brother, Mark Wright, 31, also face first-degree cruelty charges and charges related to concealing a death.

Neighbors told the Effingham County Sheriff’s Department they often saw Mary alone and working tirelessly in her yard and expressed concern for the child.

Effingham County Sheriff’s Department

Gary Bennett told WTOC:

“Other kids said at school, they could tell stuff was wrong with her hands. They were red. That was from being out in the yard out there most of the time working, doing stuff from the time she got off that bus until they would go in at night. Then she would go to school and kids would see her and ask what was wrong and she wouldn’t ever say anything. She wouldn’t open up to anybody.”

The family had been reported to Child Protective Services in the past, according to police. The children’s mother is expected to be homeless.

Posted by Elwyn Crocker on Saturday, August 21, 2010

A spokeswoman for the sheriff’s office, Gena Sullivan, told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution:

“The biggest question some of us are asking is, how did the little boy go missing for two years and nobody identified that?”

Sullivan added:

“Since this case started, we’ve had so many people come up to us and say, ‘I saw this, I saw that,’ but they didn’t call the police.”

Sheriff Jimmy McDuffie told reporters in an emotional interview:

“I’ve been doing this 41 years, and a while ago I almost broke down in tears. It’s that bad. I cannot understand how you do children like this. It’s horrible.”

Sullivan told the Daily Beast the biggest lesson to learn from this tragedy is people should always report something that just “doesn’t seem right” to police.

She said there were “months upon months” where action could have been taken to protect the kids.

About the author

Tiffani is a writer for Dearly. She is from New York City. Prior to working for Dearly she covered fashion news and managed social media for various digital media outlets.

Leave a comment

3 Replies to “Tip Leads Police to Bodies of 2 Missing Children. They Believe Their Father Buried Them Behind Their Home”

  • Anonymous 2 years ago

    I love a website devotedc entirely to parental malice and skullduggery; God knows I had to put up with plenty of it.

  • Anonymous 2 years ago

    Yes, please people….if you don’t see something that seems right, pleeeease report it! This story just breaks my heart for those poor children. I’m sure there are other like them out there, so please keep your ears and eyes open. I even look out while out driving just in case I see something out of the ordinary. Be vigilant!!

  • Michael Bankston 2 years ago

    Every state requires doctors and other professionals to report suspected cases of child abuse. In my home state, Virginia, failure to report suspected cases of child abuse within three days is classified as a misdemeanor if your line of work requires you to do so.

We are excited to announce Dearly has joined forces with Mama’s Uncut. Helping Mom’s across the United States answer questions on life’s big challenges.